• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Prospero’s Pizza

At Prospero’s Pizza, we celebrate the rich tradition of pizza-making, melding fresh, high-quality ingredients with flair and passion. Located conveniently in New Castle, Delaware, we take pride in offering a variety of delicious options—from our iconic large cheese pizza to our flavorful wings and enticing sides. With vegetarian choices and thoughtful amenities like outdoor seating and accessibility features, we cater to everyone. Customers rave about our crispy yet tender crust and flavorful sauces, making every bite a delight. Join us for an extraordinary dining experience where good friends, great food, and community come together. Welcome to Prospero’s Pizza!

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Prospero’s Pizza, a delightful gem nestled at 801 Churchmans Rd, New Castle, DE. This establishment has quickly earned a warm spot in the hearts of pizza lovers and culinary adventurers alike. With a menu that tantalizes your taste buds and options that cater to a diverse clientele, Prospero’s promises a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable.

At Prospero’s Pizza, the highlights begin with their handcrafted pies, each made with the freshest ingredients. As described by loyal customers, the pizzas boast a perfect balance of crispy yet tender dough, rich sauces, and delightful toppings. Whether you're a fan of classic cheese, piping-hot pepperoni, or hearty specialty pizzas, there is something to please every palate. With large portions and excellent flavors, it’s no wonder diners rave about their meals.

  • Vegetarian and Gluten-Free Options: Catering to various dietary needs, Prospero’s offers an array of vegetarian dishes and gluten-free pizzas, ensuring everyone can find something to enjoy.
  • Quick and Friendly Service: Guests frequently commend the staff for their quick service and warm hospitality, creating a welcoming atmosphere for families and friends.
  • Convenient Amenities: Enjoy outdoor seating, free Wi-Fi, and multiple payment options including cryptocurrency, making every visit smooth and hassle-free.
  • Catering and Delivery: Whether you're hosting an event or enjoying a cozy night in, Prospero's catering and delivery services expand their reach beyond the restaurant walls. Many customers have praised the freshness of their delivery, often noting that the food arrives hot and delicious.

Additionally, for those intrigued by flavors beyond pizza, Prospero's offers a delectable selection of appetizers, including mouthwatering mozzarella sticks, loaded fries, and savory chicken fingers. Diners have enjoyed these snacks immensely, often pairing them with their favorite pizzas for the ultimate feast.

With its combination of quality, convenience, and a friendly community vibe, Prospero’s Pizza truly stands out as a must-visit destination in New Castle. Having garnered several glowing reviews, this restaurant continues to inspire repeat visits from its loyal patrons. So, why not stop by, savor a slice, and perhaps discover your new favorite pizza place?

For reservations or to place an order, call (302) 322-9085. Prospero’s Pizza is ready to serve up happiness, one slice at a time!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Prospero’s Pizza
Allen Beryl C.
Allen Beryl C.

Good service and very clean operation. Very good wings. They also gave gluten free pizza.

Dan L.
Dan L.

I moved here from NJ a while ago, so my judging of pizza is probably more harsh than most haha. But WOOOOW this place makes the best pizza in probably the entire state!!!! Freshest taste, sauce that will make you wish they bottled and sold it and crispy and thin dough!! Absolute perfection all around!!!!

Cass M.
Cass M.

Very friendly staff with quick service. Restaurant is clean and quiet. I had just a slice of cheese pizza. It's large and very cheesy! I personally like more sauce and less cheese but I know I am in the minority with that. The pizza slice was very delicious and I'll definitely be coming back to try other items. It's been hard find good pizza in New Castle and this place is one of them.

Stephani A.
Stephani A.

Pizza was hot and delicious! Online ordering was straightforward and food was ready on time.

William R.
William R.

First time ordering. The pizza and wings were delivered hot and tasty. This is the pizza Ive been looking for the last 3 years. Spinach rolls was nice warm and fresh tasting. I will be trying other menu items based on our meal tonite. Thank You.

Juan J.
Juan J.

I ordered delivery based on the positive reviews and I was not let down. I ordered a medium pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and banana peppers and a Greek salad. When the order arrived the pizza was still warm and the salad was fresh. I was able to eat off the pizza for three meals and it still tasted good even heated in the microwave. (I was staying in a hotel‍) Granted, the mushrooms were canned, but that isn't a necessarily a deal breaker. The sauce was tasty, there was plenty of cheese and the dough was thoroughlycooked. I was pleasantly surprised by the size of the salad. Plenty of feta cheese and other toppings and a large cup of oil and vinegar dressing. The salad was more than enough for three people if you paired it with a meal. I would definitely eat here again.

Jamie T.
Jamie T.

Awesome pizza! My husband loves the cheesesteak as well. This is pizza done right, a solid pie. Not too thick, not too thin, good crust, not too much sauce, sauce has a sweetness to it, good cheese as well